AboutMenusSpecials & EventsPressContact & Directions

New Year's Menu

Served New Year's Eve & New Year's Day


Butcher's Board 18.

Cappicola, prosciutto and soppressata coupled with assorted Artisan cheeses served with crispy flatbread, grilled pita and hummus (recommended for 2 people)

Grilled Octopus 16.

Char-grilled octopus served over tortilla chips with pico de gallo, queso fresco and topped with a spicy charred tomato, jalapeño and avocado sauce

Shrimp Cocktail 15.

Jumbo shrimp served chilled with zesty cocktail sauce and lemon


Pecan Crusted Codfish 28.

Block Island codfish broiled with a pecan crust, topped with a raspberry glaze and served with fingerling potatoes and fresh vegetables

Roast Long Island Duck 29.

A crisp, semi-boneless duck served over rice pilaf and fresh vegetables with a Triple Sec sauce

Prime Rib* 32.

Slow roasted all natural prime rib served with au jus, horseradish sauce, baked potato and fresh vegetables

Bottle Special

1/2 Price La Luna Prosecco, Italy

*Consuming raw or undercooked meat, fish, shellfish and eggs may increase your risk of food borne illness, especially if you have certain medical conditions. **Menu items and pricing are subject to change.

Indian Wells Tavern  |  177 Main Street, Amagansett NY  |  631-267-0400  |  info@indianwellstavern.com  |  Find Us on Facebook